Saturday, 14 December 2013

Carluke Wargames Club 14/12/13 - Battlegroup Overlord trial game (20mm Battlegroup Overlord Review)

Earlier in the year I had picked up a copy of the Battlegroup series of rules from The Plastic Soldier Company.  I was interested in this set of rules as they are designed for 15 - 20mm, and allow for the use of Flames of War based infantry. I have a copy of the small rule book and the larger hardback Battlegroup Overlord campaign book.

Me and YD have talked about trying a game of this and last Saturday decided to give it a shot. Given that we would be learning the rules and that to start off with using individually based infantry would probably help, we decided to use some of YD's collection of 20mm figures.

So, what did we think?

Wow. A really really nice gaming system. Quick, simple but did exactly what we thought things should do. Granular with out being overcomplicated and we both picked it up really quickly. The orders system really forces you to make choices each turn, pinning adds a whole new element to the game and ammo tracking on the tanks ammo added something as well.


Just to get a feel for the game, we went for a villers bocage style game. I had 2 Cromwell platoons (2 x Cromwells and 1 x Firefly) in the town, all starting the game as pinned (dismounted). I also had a platoon of infantry (2 squads and a vickers MG team) in the town.

YD had a Tiger and a platoon of German Infantry (3 squads, command squad and 3 MG teams).

Normally with the Battlegroup games your army selection details not just your unit points but also the Battle Rating each unit has. You total this Battle Rating (BR) up and keep track of it during the game. In our case we decided we should both start with a BR of 15 since it was a test game - although mine should have been around 29 (YD's was about right).


YD started with 2 officers - one Infantry commander and the Tiger commander. I started with 3 - one Infantry and two tank platoon leaders.

Each turn starts with a random number of orders being generated. In this sized game we went for 1 D6 per turn. You also get +1 order per officer you have active (not dead). Orders are pretty simple - the main ones being Move and fire, Fire and move, double time (move twice) and Open fire (fire twice). There are also options for ambush fire (fire in the enemy turn) or reactionary moves (move in opponents turn). Senior officers (in this case our infantry officers) can also issue an order that allows you to try and unpin one unit in your actual turn - rather than at the end of the turn. This involves drawing a random morale counter (increasing your force tally for the game) and then passing morale check for the pinned unit.



Morale (or stress) counters are drawn whenever a unit is pinned or destroyed. In addition a destroyed unit's BR is taken away from your BR rating. This means as you lose units your morale (stress) total goes up and your BR goes down. When your morale tally is higher than your BR, you lose. The stress tally is kept secret from the other player, and some of the counters you draw have special effects. Like mine strikes on enemy vehicles, friendly air support turning up or making a enemy unit short on ammo.

You also get morale chits when your enemy captures a objective, uses a flamethrower or you are subject to an air attack. You can also choose to draw a chit at the end of your turn in order to unpin 1D6 units. You can draw more than one chit to increase the number of dice.


The number of orders being random really makes you have to think about what your doing. Sometimes we had more orders than units to move, other times we were desperate for orders and rolled low.

The game saw YD advancing and me sitting still on ambush and unpinning some of my tanks. YD managed to knock out one Cromwell before one of my Fireflys took out the tiger.


This actually happened 3 times before my Firefly died... we decided just to rewind and keep playing as it was a test game. Funnily enough, the numbers and the dice rolls seems right. that might seem odd given the number of times the Tiger died - but we both felt the stats and the number needed on the dice roll were correct. They were what we, as gamers, expected.


We also brought a Panther on to help the Germans, as well as a mortar team to test out the artillery rules.


Ignoring the Tigers death allowed it to get pinged a lot of times with 75mm shells and kill my first Firefly - while it slowly killed Cromwells. Eventually my 2nd Firefly unpinned and killed the Tiger.

One of YD's infantry squads with 2 sub machine guns and a rifle got into a firefight with a Bren team. The rifleman was the only German in range and he proceeded to knock out the whole Bren team with some good rolls and poor cover saves. In the game there are two types of fire. Direct fire and area fire. Direct fire requires you to pass an observation test to spot the enemy and then rolls to hit based on distance, cover etc.

Area fire is more abstract but covers suppressive fire. It rarely causes wounds but often pins the squad that's being shot at. A very interesting mechanic and useful in allowing units to advance where ambush fire is a danger. Direct fire only causes pinning on a morale check, whereas area fire causes pinning on a failed cover check. A roll of 1 on the cover check sees a casualty inflicted as well.


As things worked out I reached my BR limit before YD did, so he technically won. However we kept playing for a bit just to try the infantry assault mechanics (very simple and satisfying). The length of the game saw many of my surviving tanks out of AP ammo while YD's Panther was out of HE. It became apparent that the supply trucks and the likes in the rules would actually be useful. The rules also include stuff like wire teams, ambulances, dispatch riders, Forward Air controllers, etc.

All in all this was one of the best (if not the best) WW2 game I have played. Simpler and yet more accurate and tactical than Flames of War, more granular and realistic than Rapid Fire. I can see me playing a lot more of this game, hopefully using my existing FoW model collection. I think YD liked it a lot and hopefully we can let some of the other guys get a shot (and convert them!).

I would give this game a 9 out of 10 (the rulebook and army book were a bit oddly laid out). Well worth a shot for anyone with a 15mm collection. Turns played really quickly and we both picked it up really quickly.







10 comments:

  1. wow Jamie, that does sound excellent! The different fire types sounds realistic like troops laying down fire on the enemy to keep their heads down in support as well as direct fire with an aim of trying to kill the enemy.

    Do you think it is simple enough for me to try?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Very simple set of rules Paul, shouldn't be any problem learning them. The mini rule book I have is a quarter of the size of the flames of war one. I really enjoyed them and I'm pretty enthused about them. Especially if I can use my figures for both this and FoW.

    ReplyDelete
  3. O wow, just your description of the ruleset sounds great. I take it each trooper has to be individually based? Or can you run them in sections with FoW bases? I just don't want to have to paint any more infantry! :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. You can use FoW basing, but would need to mark casualties somehow. I'm thinking either small dice, tiddlywinks and a sharpie or worst case having to base a few individual models...

    ReplyDelete
  5. how about just having a roster sheet and keeping note of each units losses?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Could work Paul, but a bit prone to getting squads mixed up or forgetting to take a note? Dice works for naps... Might base a few up individually or something... Will see! Other issue as Brits would be being able to have my inf squads split and desperate off the Bren team...

    ReplyDelete
  7. Nice report :) BG is a very nice game

    ReplyDelete
  8. Cool report chap... Nice.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Piers, you guys have really done a great job on this game.

      Delete

Please feel free to leave a comment - it will appear once moderated! Thanks!